January 5, 2026
After more than two years of investigation, Melbourne Police have made an arrest in connection with a fatal pedestrian hit-and-run crash that occurred in March 2023. The case has drawn renewed attention to pedestrian safety and accountability on Florida roadways, particularly for those seeking guidance from our Melbourne, FL pedestrian accident lawyer following serious incidents.
According to police, officers responded on March 6, 2023, to reports of a vehicle-versus-pedestrian crash near Babcock Street and Seminole Avenue in Melbourne. When first responders arrived, they found 62-year-old Michael J. Forrest suffering from severe injuries after being struck by a white SUV traveling northbound. The driver initially stopped but then fled the scene without rendering aid, leaving the victim critically injured.
Investigators later determined the suspect vehicle was a 2011–2016 white Jeep Compass that likely had damage to its driver-side headlight and fog light. Through forensic analysis, video review, and witness interviews, detectives identified the driver as Paul William Torres of Palm Bay. Authorities say Torres was driving with a suspended license at the time of the crash.
On October 30, 2025, police issued a warrant charging Torres with Leaving the Scene of a Crash with Death and Driving with a Suspended License with Death. He was taken into custody without incident on November 3, 2025, and turned over to the Brevard County Sheriff’s Office. While the investigation focused heavily on criminal accountability, the case also highlights the broader civil issues that often arise when pedestrians are struck by vehicles.
How Pedestrian Accident Claims May Apply
Serious pedestrian crashes frequently lead victims and families to explore their legal options beyond criminal proceedings. Civil claims can focus on accountability, financial recovery, and long-term stability after a devastating incident. Our pedestrian injury lawyers often assist families dealing with medical expenses, lost income, and emotional trauma following collisions involving walkers, joggers, or individuals crossing busy roadways.
Hit-and-run cases, in particular, present unique challenges. Our hit-and-run lawyers understand how law enforcement investigations, insurance coverage, and uninsured motorist claims may intersect. Even when a driver is later identified, civil claims may involve complicated timelines and evidence review, especially when injuries occur outside marked crosswalks or along busy corridors.
In Melbourne and surrounding communities, pedestrian crashes may also involve sidewalks, shoulders, or unmarked crossings. Our traffic injury lawyers regularly evaluate whether speeding, distracted driving, or failure to yield contributed to a collision. These factors can play a significant role in determining liability and available compensation.
Working with our Melbourne pedestrian accident attorneys allows injured pedestrians and families to better understand their rights under Florida law. Legal guidance may help clarify insurance claims, wrongful death considerations, and steps to preserve evidence following a serious crash.
At Tuttle Larsen, P.A., our approach focuses on clarity, responsiveness, and compassionate advocacy during difficult moments. If you or your family are facing questions after a pedestrian collision, our Melbourne pedestrian accident lawyers can help you explore your options with confidence. We offer free consultations and are ready to answer all of your questions. And since we’re available 24/7, you never have to wonder if we’ll pick up the phone. Don’t wait—now is the time to reach out for legal support. Contact Tuttle Larsen, P.A. today to schedule a consultation and learn how our team can support you during this challenging time.
