Florida Personal Injury Attorney
  • Home
  • Our Attorneys
    • Douglas W. Tuttle
    • Dana C. Larsen
    • Jesse H. Larsen
  • Practice Areas
    • Bicycle Accidents
    • Criminal Defense
    • Dog Bite Accidents
    • Motorcycle Accidents
    • Motor Vehicle Accidents
    • Pedestrian Accidents
    • Premises Liability
    • Slip-And-Fall Accidents
    • Traumatic Brain Injuries
    • Trucking Accidents
    • Wrongful Death
  • Results
  • Blog
  • Reviews
  • Contact
  • 772-563-0032

Maniglia v. Carpenter

Home / Firm News / Maniglia v. Carpenter
January 6, 2016
Firm News

Maniglia v. Carpenter
November 4, 2015
3rd DCA

Improper Evidence Exclusion

The 3rd DCA recently held that a trial court wrongly excluded evidence of a Plaintiff’s drunken golf cart ride and subsequent police brawl. In September 2009, a vehicle driven by Maniglia and a vehicle driven by Carpenter collided on I-95. Carpenter alleged that upon changing lanes, Maniglia swerved into him and sideswiped his vehicle, while Maniglia maintained that it was just a bump.

Carpenter saw a chiropractor the day after the accident. Several weeks later Carpenter played in a golf tournament and drove a golf cart out onto the road, ran a red light, and collided with another car. The police showed up to the scene, and Carpenter got into a brawl with the officers that included kicking and wrestling.

There was evidence that Carpenter was intoxicated; that he did not have permission to use the golf cart; that he yelled profanity at the police and kicked both feet against the rear passenger window of the police car; and that he was arrested on the scene for battery on a law enforcement officer. Carpenter failed to report this incident to his chiropractor, and evidence submitted by Maniglia showed that Carpenter’s surgery recommendation was only made after the golf cart accident.

The trial court only allowed certain portions of this golf cart incident to come into evidence. The 3rd DCA stated that the golf cart incident included facts that addressed both Carpenter’s credibility and his proof of causation, and Carpenter’s failure to mention the recent golf cart incident to his chiropractor may have affected the jury’s evaluation of Carpenter’s credibility. The court also held that the particulars of his fall and struggle with police would have been an adequate basis for jury instructions on intervening causes and subsequent injuries.

The court reversed and remanded for a new trial. It is important to remember that a judge is the gatekeeper of evidence. If the judge deems the evidence will be useful to a jury in rendering their decision, that evidence will come in. At Tuttle Law, P.A. we understand the importance of these evidentiary decisions, and we prepare arguments for multiple scenarios.

http://caselaw.findlaw.com/fl-district-court-of-appeal/1717449.html

Share
Next Post
State Farm v. Gold
Contact Us Today

Get your free case review within 24 hours. All Fields Required.





    How Would You Like To Be Contacted?
    PhoneEmail
    Brief Description of Your Legal Issue

    Disclaimer | Privacy Policy
    I have read the disclaimer *

    Florida Injury Law Firm

    Tuttle Law, P.A.

    Vero Beach Office

    3617 20th St.
    Vero Beach, FL 32960

    Call us 24/7 to schedule a free consultation:

    Phone: 772-563-0032
    Fax: 772-563-2134

    Also serving Sebastian FL,  Port St. Lucie FL,
    Fort Pierce FL and Indian River County

    Tuttle Law, P.A.
    • About
    • Contact Tuttle Law, P.A.
    • Disclaimer
    • Privacy Policy
    Attorneys
    • Douglas W. Tuttle
    • Dana C. Larsen
    • Jesse H. Larsen
    Resources:
    • Bicycle Accident Lawyer Vero Beach, FL
    • Car Accident Lawyer Vero Beach, FL
    • Lyft Accident Lawyer Vero Beach, FL
    • Motorcycle Accident Lawyer Vero Beach, FL
    • Pedestrian Accident Lawyer Vero Beach, FL
    • Personal Injury Lawyer Sebastian, FL
    • Premises Liability Lawyer Sebastian, FL
    • Slip and Fall Lawyer Sebastian, FL
    • Uber Accident Lawyer Vero Beach, FL
    • Wrongful Death Lawyer Vero Beach, FL

    Copyright Tuttle Law, P.A. © 2021. All Rights Reserved. Powered By Matador Solutions - Sitemap

    • Blog
    • Home
    • Our Attorneys
      • Douglas W. Tuttle
      • Dana C. Larsen
      • Jesse H. Larsen
    • Practice Areas
      • Bicycle Accidents
      • Criminal Defense
      • Dog Bite Accidents
      • Motorcycle Accidents
      • Motor Vehicle Accidents
      • Pedestrian Accidents
      • Premises Liability
      • Slip-And-Fall Accidents
      • Traumatic Brain Injuries
      • Trucking Accidents
      • Wrongful Death
    • Results
    • Blog
    • Reviews
    • Contact