Florida Personal Injury Attorney
  • Home
  • Our Attorneys
    • Douglas W. Tuttle
    • Dana C. Larsen
    • Jesse H. Larsen
    • Caroline I. Mockler
  • Practice Areas
    • Bicycle Accidents
    • Criminal Defense
    • Dog Bite Accidents
    • Motorcycle Accidents
    • Motor Vehicle Accidents
    • Pedestrian Accidents
    • Premises Liability
    • Slip-And-Fall Accidents
    • Traumatic Brain Injuries
    • Trucking Accidents
    • Wrongful Death
  • Results
  • Reviews
  • Contact
  • 772-348-2828 | 24/7 Call Answering

Expert Affidavits and Summary Judgment

Home / Firm News / Expert Affidavits and Summary Judgment
April 7, 2017
Firm News

In a recent case, McNabb v. Taylor Elevator Corp., a man sued an elevator company after he slipped in elevator oil and was injured.

[2016 Fla. App. LEXIS 12395 (Fla. Dist. Ct. App. 2d Dist.)].  The elevator company claimed that it was not responsible and offered evidence showing that the elevator had been inspected three days prior to the incident in which the man was injured. Based on this evidence, the elevator company filed a motion, asking the court to grant summary judgment in favor of the elevator company.

Summary judgment is a procedural device used in litigation to quickly dismiss a case without a trial. It is used when one party believes that there is no dispute as to the material facts of the case and that they should be entitled to judgment as a matter of law. As a general rule, courts are supposed to act cautiously when considering a motion for summary judgment and should only grant summary judgment when there is absolutely no basis for a jury verdict in favor of the moving party.

In response to the elevator company’s motion for summary judgment, McNabb’s attorneys submitted an affidavit from an expert, Charles Benedict. In the affidavit, Mr. Benedict offered his opinion that the leak had been occurring between a 4.5 and 18 day period prior to the inspection, based on a drip test, the depth of the oil, the dimensions of the machine room, and the engineer’s observation of the drip rate. The elevator company maintained that the leak occurred after the inspection.

The trial court granted the elevator company’s motion for summary judgment stating: “I’m going to discount this affidavit of Charles Benedict, because I don’t believe it’s based on any actual facts.” On appeal, McNabb’s attorneys argued that the affidavit created a material issue of fact and that summary judgment was improper. The Second District Court of Appeals reversed the decision and held that the trial court improperly weighed the evidence when it chose to discount the affidavit.

When an affidavit creates a material issue of fact courts should not participate in the weighing of evidence and take the case from a jury. Quoting the case Nard, Inc. v. DeVito Contracting & Supply, Inc. the court in McNabb noted: “[T]he merest possibility of the existence of a genuine issue of material fact precludes the entry of final summary judgment.”

Share
Previous Post
Technology in Cars
Next Post
Mandatory Bodily Injury Liability Coverage
Contact Us Today

Get your free case review within 24 hours. All Fields Required.





    How Would You Like To Be Contacted?
    PhoneEmail
    Brief Description of Your Legal Issue

    Disclaimer | Privacy Policy
    I have read the disclaimer *

    Florida Injury Law Firm

    Tuttle Larsen, P.A.

    Vero Beach Office

    3617 20th St.
    Vero Beach, FL 32960

    Call us 24/7 to schedule a free consultation:

    New Clients: 772-348-2828
    Existing Clients: 772-563-0032
    Fax: 772-563-2134

    Also serving Sebastian FL,  Port St. Lucie FL, Fort Pierce FL, Palm Bay FL, Indian River County FL and Melbourne FL

    Tuttle Larsen, P.A.
    • About
    • Blog
    • Contact Tuttle Larsen, P.A.
    • Disclaimer
    • Privacy Policy
    Attorneys
    • Caroline I. Mockler
    • Dana C. Larsen
    • Jesse H. Larsen
    Resources:
    • Bicycle Accident Lawyer Melbourne, FL
    • Fort Pierce Car Accident Lawyer
    • Melbourne Car Accident Lawyer
    • Palm Bay Car Accident Lawyer
    • Port St. Lucie Car Accident Lawyer
    • Car Accident Lawyer Vero Beach, FL
    • Criminal Defense Lawyer Vero Beach, FL
    • Criminal Defense Lawyer Sebastian, FL
    • Uber Accident Lawyer Vero Beach, FL
    • Bicycle Accident Lawyer Sebastian, FL
    • Personal Injury Lawyer Vero Beach, FL
    • Car Accident Lawyer Indian River County, FL

    Copyright Tuttle Larsen, P.A. © 2022. All Rights Reserved. | SEO for Lawyers Powered by Matador Solutions - Sitemap

    • Blog
    • Home
    • Our Attorneys
      • Douglas W. Tuttle
      • Dana C. Larsen
      • Jesse H. Larsen
      • Caroline I. Mockler
    • Practice Areas
      • Bicycle Accidents
      • Criminal Defense
      • Dog Bite Accidents
      • Motorcycle Accidents
      • Motor Vehicle Accidents
      • Pedestrian Accidents
      • Premises Liability
      • Slip-And-Fall Accidents
      • Traumatic Brain Injuries
      • Trucking Accidents
      • Wrongful Death
    • Results
    • Reviews
    • Contact